Banner image placeholder
Banner image

An Improved Whiskey Cocktail with Cherry and Absinthe


When an Old Fashioned wears a suit


November 08, 2026

Improved Whiskey Cocktail in a rocks glass with lemon twist atop a wooden table.
Improved Whiskey Cocktail by the Author

It’s November, and here in the Appalachian Speakeasy that means we need a light dusting of whiskey cocktails to lead us into the Thanksgiving holidays. This week's drink is simple and deceptively tasty. A dizzying array of cocktail recipes exists. But almost all cocktails descend from about 4–6 base templates, most of which existed before the 20th century. Maybe the most important of these, as we discussed in Festival Apple, is the Old Fashioned template. Most of the drinks we know as cocktails today originated in the 1800s, with a few truly old exceptions, like eggnogs (~1300s), flips (~1600s), and sangarees (~1700s). The Old Fashioned was born in the 1800s. In its early forms, a “cocktail” generally meant spirits (some say the original “old fashioned” might even have been a gin cocktail), sugar, and bitters, adorned with a flourish of garnish.

When the Godfather of cocktails, Jerry Thomas, came on the scene, he used these basic templates to create an imbibing culture around personalized drinks that had previously been the province of punch. See David Wondrich for an accounting of this transition. From that original spec for an Old Fashioned as spirit, bitters, and sugar, he began to build out subtle variations and even new drinks from scratch, which still gave a nod to these basic templates. One extension of the template is an “improved” cocktail, which simply means taking the Old Fashioned template and adding Maraschino and Absinthe as flavor accents. And that’s an important point. They weren’t meant to replace or dominate the base spirit, but to accent its flavor profile, heighten flavor notes already in the spirit, and offer myriad possibilities for different flavors from the same template.

After creating these “improved” variations, Thomas went on to spearhead a separate class of augmentations he dubbed “Fancy” Cocktails. These usually included Curaçao and a swipe and addition of lemon peel. Since sometimes more is more and at other times less is more, we’re making the Improved Whiskey Cocktail this week in the Speakeasy. Since we’re expressing and adding our lemon twist and using a split base of whiskies, we might even dub this drink a Fancy Improved Whiskey Cocktail. This is a nuanced, subtle, and truly great drink that gives you the best of both worlds from American whiskey styles.

Let’s tip one.

Improved Whiskey Cocktail

Potion:
  • 1 oz Straight rye whiskey
  • 1 oz Bourbon whiskey
  • 1 bsp Luxardo Maraschino liqueur
  • 1 Spritz or 1 dash Absinthe
  • 1⁄4 oz Gomme syrup
  • 2 dashes Boker’s Style (Cardamom) bitters
  • 2 drops 20% saline
  • Lemon twist garnish
Procedure:

First, I know that looks like a lot of ingredients above, but it’s really a bunch of small flavor accents for the whiskey split-base. Chill your glass thoroughly. This is a stirred cocktail. Add all ingredients, sans Absinthe and garnish, to a mixing glass. Load the mixing glass with a mix of large bergs and medium shards of ice. Stir until well chilled, then fine-strain into your glass. Spritz the top with the Absinthe from an atomizer. Then, express the lemon oils from the twist and garnish. Enjoy!

Glass: Rocks glass

Options:

As mentioned above in our short history lesson, improved cocktails are tweaks on the basic, original cocktail formula of spirit, bitters, and sugar. So, substituting the split whiskey base above with any other spirit, or a split base of spirits, gives you a new cocktail—the “Improved” brandy or gin cocktail, for instance. You could even pair a rum you like with a tropical liqueur.

You can also use only bourbon or rye. One thing to note: try to keep the flavors in balance. Most bourbons are not made with corn alone. Their malt bills (the recipe for the grain ratios in the whiskey) usually contain rye, wheat, oats, and barley in some measure. You can categorize bourbons as being “high-rye” (e.g., Four Roses) or a “wheater” (e.g., Weller and the infamous Pappy Van Winkle). If you’re using a “high-rye” bourbon, you may be better served altering the ratios above. If you’re using a “wheated” bourbon, you might prefer a little more rye to bourbon. As for rye whiskies, I really like High West’s Double Rye for spice or Rittenhouse for that rye maltiness. I used Double Rye above.

In the recipe above, I used a local bourbon-style whiskey from Blackdraft Distillery in Martinsburg, West Virginia, where my daughter and her partner live. If you’re passing through West Virginia’s eastern panhandle, it is well worth the detour. The spirits are made very well, and the venue is world-class. Blackdraft’s Straight Bourbon is “double oaked,” which means more vanilla, caramel, and toffee notes, along with a bit of spice from a 15% rye addition in the malt bill. The extra caramel, vanilla, and toffee are welcome here because they help the bourbon stand up to the Double Rye. The bourbon is also 96 proof, so if you aren’t using a similar overproof version, it’ll be a little less bracing. All Old Fashioneds and their riffs are spirit-forward, and mine is even more so, on purpose. So, keep that in mind as you mix.

Technically, an “Improved” cocktail should have Maraschino and Absinthe. But you can certainly play with these, especially the Maraschino, which you can substitute with orange, floral, or nut liqueurs. I can personally tell you that Crème de Mûre is a great substitute for Maraschino in this drink. But we all know I’m a blackberry fiend. Use flavors you know pair with the base spirit, like blended scotch and raspberry liqueur (e.g., Chambord).

Use the syrup in amounts that yield the sweetness you prefer. You could certainly use regular old simple syrup. Gomme syrup is traditional and adds a more viscous mouthfeel. In the 19th century, gomme syrup was made using acacia gum, which emulsified and thickened the syrup. As for bitters, you can use aromatic bitters, but it won’t be as “improved” as this version. Garnish with what you enjoy. I tend to use lemon to brighten up the rich flavor of Maraschino, but you could use an orange twist or double down on the cherry in the Maraschino with a cocktail cherry. As I have done many times, I encourage you to rinse the cherry, as its syrup will alter the drink's sweetness balance.

Improved Whiskey Cocktail in a rocks glass with lemon twist atop a stone wall.
Improved Whiskey Cocktail by the Author

Join us in the Appalachian Speakeasy next week as we take on a dessert from the Indian subcontinent. Let us know how you’ve improved your version of this cocktail. And, here at the blog, we’re working on an Improved Tequila Cocktail for my good friend Bryan. If you like that notion, tell us how you’d do it in the comments.

This blog is, as ever, an opinionated take on drinks.


Share
Text Only Owlstown
QR Code
Translate to